Special Focus
18-county electronic medical record system takes shape
Around The Region
Oberstar introduces transportation bill
On The Move
Belly dancers want respect for the art
News Makers
July NewsMakers
Construction
UMD's Red Plan impact study stirs controversy

Saturday
July 4, 2009

Business News
CNNfn
CBSMarketwatch
Bloomberg
Reuters
BusinessWeek
PRNewswire

Political News
Salon
Slate
The Atlantic
The Nation
Mother Jones

Sports
ESPN
Local Sports

 
 
 
Send A Letter To The Editor
 
Letters To The Editor



Charlotte Neigh, co-chair, Citizens Against the Mesaba Project (CAMP)
Bovey, MN
 
5/5/2009 4:09:05 PM

Mesaba Energy claims disputed

It is not correct to say the federal government would back 73 percent of the total cost, or the federal government has “pledged” $800 million in loan guarantees, or municipal utilities would have to raise only 27 percent of the project costs to secure ownership of Unit 1 of the Mesaba Project (“No customer for controversial energy project,” April 2008).
Excelsior Energy has not yet been awarded any loan guarantees. It is one of 11 final applicants to share in a pool of $4 billion. Excelsior admits its negotiations with the U.S. Department of Energy will continue throughout 2009. DOE stated in October 2007 that projects relying upon a smaller guarantee percentage will be given greater weight. Despite this statement, Excelsior repeatedly has misled the media and even the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission about the status of the loan guarantees, suggesting the federal agency would cover 80 percent of the project costs.
Apparently Excelsior is now seeking 73 percent, but this is a long way from becoming reality. A key requirement for qualifying is to have an assurance of revenues to be generated from sale of the product. This means a long-term commitment from a customer to purchase the energy. This is why the failure to achieve a PPA (power purchase agreement) with Xcel Energy is critical. Other obstacles are DOE requirements for: credit assessment without a loan guarantee; approval of environmental and other permits; reduced greenhouse gases; and relative amount of cash contributed by the principals.
Now Excelsior is trying to entice municipal utilities into purchasing ownership interests by suggesting that 100 percent ownership can be obtained by raising 27 percent of the costs. Municipal utilities should carefully assess the likelihood that this amount or any loan guarantees at all will be awarded for the Mesaba Project before issuing bonds to finance such a purchase.
More information and analysis about the federal loan guarantees is available by scrolling down to the Oct. 8, 2007 entry on the CAMP Web site.

Previous Letters To The Editor:
e-newsletter
 
Cheqtel web site
 
Faster Solutions ad
 
Max Gray
 
 
Site Map
Home Page
About Us
Advertising
Archives
Around the Region
BN Columnists
BN Lists
Business Law
Business Mentor
Calendar
Coaches Corner
Construction
Daily Briefing
Editorials
Exclusives
Investing
Letters to the Editor
News From KUWS
News From KDAL
Marketing
Newsmakers
Nonprofit Hotline
On the Move
Press Releases
Search
Send Us News
Special Focus
Stock Charts
Buy Online!
Technology
Tell Us What You Think
 

 

BusinessNorth
101 W. 2nd St. Suite 202
Duluth, MN 55802
Phone: 218-720-3060
Fax: 218-720-3112


Privacy Policy ©2001 DCS Netlink www.dcsnetlink.com

Minnesota and Wisconsin’s source for the latest news on forest products, construction, real estate, conference centers, tourism, and Minnesota mining. Serving Duluth, Grand Rapids, and Ely MN. As well as, Ashland, Spooner, Bayfield and Hurlley, Superior WI.
Duluth newspaper, Minnesota, Wisconsin, newspaper online, Duluth mn news, Minnesota mining, Ashland WI, Hurley WI Spooner WI, Grand Rapids MN, Ely MN, Bayfield MN, Superior WI, forest products, mining, Minnesota business, Minnesota real estate, Wisconsin Business, business news, Duluth Business